The second LMA Underwriting Talent Summit brought together senior underwriting leaders from across the Lloyd’s market to focus on a fundamental question: how do we create a market where female underwriters can progress, lead and excel at the highest levels?
Opening the summit, Sheila Cameron, CEO at the LMA, reflected on the data that prompted us to convene the market again. While the female underwriting pipeline has seen positive changes overall, the actual proportion of female CUOs and lead underwriters has actually decreased by one percentage point.
Across the day, discussions challenged assumptions about what successful careers and leaders look like, explored how organisations can better support female talent and considered how AI could reshape career development.
Rethinking career progression
A consistent message from underwriting leaders was that successful careers are rarely linear. Lateral moves, changes in class of business and moves across continents may be outside of comfort zones, but all provide valuable experience.
The same applied at the most senior levels, where CEOs challenged the myth that reaching the top requires a carefully mapped-out career plan. Instead, careers evolve through a combination of opportunity, ambition, luck and a willingness to take calculated risks.
For organisations, that means recognising that progression does not always mean promotion. Giving people stretch assignments and opportunities to broaden their experience can be critical to preparing the next generation of underwriting leaders.
Sponsorship and opportunity
Sponsorship remains an important part of turning potential into progression. A sponsor advocates for somebody when they are not in the room, puts their name forward and creates opportunities for them to demonstrate their abilities.
Panellists noted that sponsorship is not necessarily formal, nor does it require one career-defining intervention. Small but consistent acts of sponsorship can compound over time, building an individual’s visibility both within and outside an organisation.
Senior leaders were encouraged to play an active role: identify talented women, open doors, provide meaningful stretch opportunities and, importantly, not to make assumptions about the responsibilities or opportunities they want.
Challenging perceptions of leadership
The summit also challenged the idea that there is one model of a successful leader.
Leaders spoke candidly about careers shaped by uncertainty, periods of self-doubt and learning through experience. Being the loudest person in the room, having every answer or conforming to a particular leadership style is not a prerequisite for success.
This matters when identifying future talent, as those who are less likely to be vocal about their own contribution can be overlooked. Organisations need to create opportunities for different leadership styles to be visible and valued, while supporting people through the transition from technical expert to leader.
AI as a career development tool
AI brings another dimension to the talent challenge. Used well, it can help underwriters build knowledge, prepare for difficult conversations, practise negotiations and develop confidence when moving into unfamiliar areas.
However, unequal adoption risks widening existing gaps. Leaders therefore need to ensure people have opportunities to develop their AI capabilities and that the value they create through those tools translates into recognition and career opportunities.
The call to action
The message for senior leaders was:
By combining active sponsorship, career-enhancing opportunities and executive-level visibility, organisations can create an environment where female underwriters choose to progress, lead and excel at the highest levels.