At this year’s LMA Underwriting Talent Summit, a panel of senior female underwriters shared the experiences that have shaped their careers and their perspectives on the next generation of underwriting leadership.
Their career paths were rarely linear. Moves across functions, geographies, classes of business and organisations created valuable opportunities to learn, while sponsors had opened doors and encouraged them to step beyond their comfort zones. Just as importantly, setbacks and changes of direction had helped them understand where their strengths and ambitions lay.
For organisations looking to strengthen their pipeline of female underwriting talent, the discussion highlighted an important message: developing future leaders requires organisations to create the environments in which people can take risks, build a broad range of experience and navigate their own route to leadership.
Rethinking the career ladder
Some of the most formative career decisions discussed were those that did not look like obvious progression on paper.
Moves from finance roles into underwriting or across different classes of business created steep learning curves, but ultimately led to new opportunities and career growth.
In one case, an organisation supported a cross-departmental career move through a six-month secondment, allowing the individual to take a risk while providing the safety of being able to return to the previous role. That support helped give the individual the confidence to make a move that became important to her longer-term progression.
All panellists advised the audience not to wait for the perfect next role to emerge. Instead, be vocal about career ambitions and take calculated risks to reach them.
Creating opportunity, not prescribing a pathway
Against the backdrop of a changing market cycle, panellists discussed how different phases of the hard and soft market can create unexpected development opportunities.
Working in a class experiencing significant change can bring greater responsibility and accelerate learning, while a softer market can provide different opportunities to strengthen technical skills and judgement.
Organisations need to consider how they support people through those periods of accelerated development and give them the confidence to make difficult decisions, including having the conviction to say no when others are saying yes.
The panellists also spoke candidly about occasions when career opportunities had not worked out and their confidence had been knocked. Recognising that a role was not right and changing direction was itself valuable and should be reinterpreted as a learning opportunity, rather than a failure.
Sponsorship is built through small moments
Sponsorship emerged as another important factor in progression.
Rather than a single senior individual transforming someone’s career, the panel described the cumulative effect of ‘micro-sponsorship’: repeatedly bringing somebody’s name into conversations, recommending them for opportunities and encouraging them to take on assignments outside their comfort zone.
Those relationships were often organic – born from a coffee or even a LinkedIn message that developed into a sponsorship-type relationship over time.
While individuals still need to make their ambitions visible in order to progress, senior leaders have a significant role to play. Those with influence should actively use it to open doors and make talented people visible to executive leadership.
Broadening our idea of leadership
The panel also challenged assumptions about what an underwriting leader should look or sound like.
The discussion highlighted the importance of developing a leadership approach that felt authentic to them. While modelling certain leadership behaviours and incorporating them into your own style is beneficial, entirely replicating the style of a previous leader could be exhausting and ineffective.
Successful underwriting leadership was described as increasingly collaborative, with a need to bring together the right people with the right expertise and be comfortable not having every answer.
That becomes particularly important as underwriting itself changes. Future leaders will need more than technical expertise and commercial performance – they will need to embrace technology and change, understand the capabilities within their teams and lead effectively through uncertainty.
What should underwriting leaders do differently?
Perhaps the strongest message from the discussion was that there is no single definition of a successful underwriting career.
Not everybody has the same career ambitions. Success for some might mean becoming a deep technical expert in their class, prioritising the ‘team at home’ as much as the team in the office or taking on a different kind of leadership responsibility.
For organisations, that means recognising different ambitions and equipping individuals with the skills they need to reach their career goals.
For the next generation, the advice was to have more courage and less fear, say yes to opportunities, make mistakes and chase perfection a little less.