There is a tendency to look at those who reach the top of an organisation and assume their path was deliberate: a clear career destination, the right experience at the right time and an innate readiness to lead.
At the LMA Underwriting Talent Summit, a panel of C-suite leaders from across the Lloyd’s market challenged some common perceptions of leadership. Their routes to leadership had been varied and unpredictable – careers were shaped by opportunity, difficult decisions, mistakes and others willing to push them beyond what they thought they were ready for.
Myth 1: Successful leaders always had a plan
None of the leaders described following a carefully mapped career path. Instead, opportunities arose through unexpected changes of direction and a willingness to take on challenges without knowing exactly where they would lead.
Rather than focusing on a particular title, careers had often been shaped by a desire to make an impact and a willingness to take greater responsibility in their work.
That willingness did not always come naturally. Stepping into a role without knowing all the answers could feel uncomfortable, particularly when there was pressure to demonstrate expertise. Supportive leaders played an important role by encouraging people into opportunities they might not otherwise have put themselves forward for.
The lesson was not to abandon career planning altogether – panellists encouraged always having a plan for the next career step – but to ensure the plan doesn’t become a constraint on opportunities that come your way.
Myth 2: It gets harder the more senior you get
The discussion challenged the assumption that careers become progressively more difficult with seniority.
Instead, the toughest period can come in the middle of the career ladder, where individuals are simultaneously developing technical expertise, continuing to deliver day-to-day work and beginning to lead teams. These years also often coincide with significant responsibilities outside work, particularly childcare and other caring responsibilities.
Senior leadership brings greater accountability, but it can also bring greater autonomy. Leaders can build strong teams around them, retain control over their time and focus on where they add the greatest value.
The panellists agreed that leadership is no longer about doing everything yourself. Experienced leaders learn to rely on people who are better at particular tasks than they are, giving those people opportunities to develop and shine.
The panel also challenged the perception that progression inevitably means sacrificing flexibility, particularly when it comes to childcare responsibilities.
Organisations have an important part to play in support around parental transitions, exploring approaches such as job-sharing that enable talent to remain in the pipeline.
Myth 3: Leaders knew they were ready
Leadership is a skill learned through experience rather than mastered before taking the role. Panellists described stepping into senior positions with a degree of uncertainty and relying on the support of the teams around them.
Moving from being the person who solves every problem to the person who enables a team to solve them can be one of the most important transitions into leadership. Experience gradually helps leaders to join the dots, see the bigger picture and know when to draw on the expertise of others.
The panellists also noted that there is not a single personality type suited to leadership. For those more introverted, it can feel challenging in environments where extroversion is highly visible. However, effective leadership comes from taking the time to understand your own strengths, rather than trying to replicate somebody else’s style.
Myth 4: Talent naturally rises to the top
Talent alone does not guarantee progression. Those who are less comfortable promoting their contribution or simply less visible to senior decision makers can easily be overlooked. For organisations, that makes visibility, sponsorship and allyship important parts of building a stronger leadership pipeline.
That can involve creating opportunities for high-potential talent to present to leadership teams, attend Board discussions, take visible roles at external events or build relationships with leaders beyond their immediate reporting line.
Organisational networks and communities can also create valuable support for those navigating their journey to leadership, particularly when the people they are intended to benefit have a say in how those initiatives are designed.
Myth 5: There is only one model of a successful leader
One of the biggest myths is that leaders need to arrive fully formed: confident, decisive and equipped with all the answers.
The reality described by the panel was more human: imposter syndrome, mistakes and uncertainty featured throughout their careers. Leadership styles were developed through trial and error, observing others and consciously adopting techniques that worked for them.
The message from the discussion was ultimately a reassuring one: there is no perfect blueprint for reaching your career ambitions. Senior leaders make mistakes, learn from experience and continue to evolve.
For organisations seeking to strengthen their pipeline of female underwriting leaders, making that reality more visible matters. The more accessible and varied leadership looks, and the more opportunities talented people have to test themselves before they feel completely ready, the broader the pool of people who can see themselves getting there.